Just Let ‘Shoeless Joe’ Rest in Peace

Greenville's Fluor Field includes a small museum devoted to native son Shoeless Joe Jackson. (Monte Dutton photo)

Greenville’s Fluor Field includes a small museum devoted to native son Shoeless Joe Jackson. (Monte Dutton photo)

Clinton, South Carolina, Tuesday, September 1, 2015, 7:27 a.m.

I heard last night the new baseball commissioner, Rob Manfred, was going to make a new ruling on the case of “Shoeless Joe” Jackson, and I naturally figured he was going to be reinstated.

Monte Dutton

Monte Dutton

It’s not going to affect the pennant races. Jackson was banned ninety-four years ago. He’s no longer available to pinch-hit. He died while Truman was president.

But Manfred said no for no apparent reason. It makes no sense to reopen a case that’s nine-four-years old and then announce there’s no change.

Ah, thought about it. Then I said, uh, naaahhhhh.

Since I am a South Carolinian, I’ve known the story of Shoeless Joe Jackson since my earliest memory, and while I’ve always been sympathetic — he was a poor, illiterate kid from a mill neighborhood with incredible skill and precious little discernment — I’ve also thought him guilty.

Jackson may not have participated in the Chicago White Sox’ throwing of the 1919 World Series, but he knew about the plot. I hate it for him.

Lots of people grow more demanding as they grow older. I grow more tolerant.

What changed my mind was the remark of one Ted Williams, who, once upon a time, traveled to Cooperstown to lobby for Jackson’s reinstatement.

Supposedly, Williams said something along the lines of, “Only baseball would ban a man for life and then keep him banned fifty years after he was dead.” As I recall, Williams’ language was a tad saltier.

I read that quotation in a book a few years ago but couldn’t find either the book or an online source this morning. I did discover that Williams said, in 1998, “Out of baseball for life, he served his sentence. He died while under that ban.”

Williams died in 2002.

So what was this? A publicity stunt?

Ladies and gentleman, the grand and omniscient Commissioner of Baseball has deigned to reopen the case of one Joseph Jefferson Jackson. After pondering the matter at the peak of Kennesaw Mountain, the Commissioner has concluded …

… Guilty!

It makes no more sense than a man who batted .375 and scored from first base on a single actually, at the same time, losing the World Series on purpose.

Manfred might as well have desecrated Shoeless Joe’s grave.

Now I have my third opinion on the subject: Leave the man be.


(Design by Jennifer Skutelsky)

(Design by Jennifer Skutelsky)

Take a look at my novel, Crazy of Natural Causes. It’s not about sports, but there’s lots of football in it. http://www.amazon.com/Crazy-Natural-Causes-Monte-Dutton-ebook/dp/B00YI8SWUU/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1436215069&sr=1-1&keywords=Crazy+of+Natural+Causes

While you’re at it, download a Kindle app. It’s easy. It’s free. Reading one of my novels might give you something to do besides play Candy Crush Saga. Whatever that is. http://www.amazon.com/Monte-Dutton/e/B005H3B144/ref=sr_ntt_srch_lnk_1?qid=1416767492&sr=8-1

About Monte

For 20 seasons, I mostly wrote about NASCAR. I'm still paying attention, but I'm spending more of my time these days writing novels and songs. I try to blog regularly on whatever happens to strike my fancy.
This entry was posted in Sports and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.